Meteorite dust holds records of magnetism that may have helped form the sun

Around 4.6 billion years ago, the solar system was little more than a giant ball of gas and dust. Over the next few million years, this “solar nebula” underwent a huge transformation, flattening into a disk of matter that then condensed to form the central sun and orbiting planets. Scientists have assumed that the early solar system was shaped mainly through gravity. But a new study finds that magnetism also likely played a role. MIT scientists have discovered records of ancient magnetism in the oldest samples of meteorites known today. The team analyzed microscopic grains embedded in a meteorite that was discovered in Antarctica in 2008. These grains, called calcium-aluminum-rich inclusions, or CAIs, originally formed during the solar system’s first 200,000 years, making the samples the oldest known solar system material.The findings suggest that a magnetic field existed very early on, during the time of the solar nebula. The researchers estimate that this nebular magnetic field was stronger than Earth’s magnetic field today, and likely played a significant role in pulling together primordial matter to form the early sun.“This transition, from a spherical cloud to a protoplanetary disk, is one of the most significant events in all of solar system history,” says Benjamin Weiss, the Robert R. Shrock Professor of Earth and Planetary Sciences at MIT. “It has long been theorized that gravity caused this, but our measurements show magnetism likely played a role.”Weiss and his colleagues report their discovery in a paper appearing this week in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. The study’s MIT co-authors are first author Cauê Borlina PhD ’22, Elias Mansbach PhD ’24, and Nilanjan Chatterjee, along with Xue-Ning Bai of Tsinghua University, Po-Yen Tung and Richard Harrison of Cambridge University, François Tissot of Caltech, and Kevin McKeegan of the University of California at Los Angeles.Spinning grainsMagnetic fields are generated by matter that is electrically charged and moving around. In the very early solar system, the collapsing cloud of gas and dust could have whipped up a plasma of charged particles. As these charges spun through the developing disk, they could have produced and sustained a magnetic field.If this were the case, Weiss and his colleagues reasoned that such early magnetism would have affected material in the disk. As this material condensed, tiny magnetic minerals would have locked in the strength of the magnetic field, preserving its original intensity over billions of years. If these minerals somehow made it to Earth for scientists to measure, their “remanent magnetization” would be evidence that a magnetic field indeed existed and could have played a role in shaping the solar system. In fact, the team has previously discovered evidence of a magnetic field, as early as 2 million years into the solar system’s formation. At that time, scientists believe that the sun was already in place, and that the planets were just starting to come together. Thus, the magnetic field Weiss measured likely played a part in the formation of the early planets.“Nowadays people don’t debate whether magnetism is present when planets are forming. But the debate is around the very early solar system, before planets are forming, when there’s just a disk,” says Borlina, who led the new study as an MIT graduate student and is now an assistant professor at Purdue University. “That’s where the debate still resides, and that’s where we’re operating now.”Magnetic recordsFor their new study, the team investigated whether a magnetic field could have existed even earlier in the solar system, when the sun was first coming together. They analyzed samples of DOM 08006, a meteorite that was discovered in 2008 in Dominion Range, a mountain range located along the East Antarctic Ice Sheet. Since it was first recovered, the meteorite has been studied extensively. DOM 08006 is one of the most primitive meteorites discovered, and it contains mineral grains that date back to the earliest stages of solar system development, possibly even before the sun was formed. Surprisingly, the meteorite has managed to keep its original composition and minerals.“Other meteorites went through many different processes over this 4.5 billion year history,” Weiss says. “They were formed in the solar nebula, then added to bodies with water, then got destroyed, moved to the asteroid belt, and then landed here. But somehow, DOM has experienced less alteration than any other meteorite.”If the early solar system did harbor a magnetic field, records of that field could still be in place in some of DOM’s ancient mineral grains, including CAIs. “We know they are the oldest things we have of the early solar system,” Borlina says. “But CAI’s are very complex and are not all the same, even within a 1-millimeter piece of the meteorite. So we have to carefully identify what types they are.” From small samples of the parent meteorite, the team isolated tiny grains and identified a handful of CAIs that contained inherently magnetic minerals such as iron. They then put the grains through a series of tests to measure any magnetism they still carry. The team identified traces of a magnetic field in the ancient grains. Based on their measurements, they estimate that a magnetic field, of about 150 to 600 microteslas, existed in the early solar system. This field strength is about three to 12 times greater than the Earth’s magnetic field today. “We think these kinds of magnetic fields were helping to move gas from the protoplanetary disk, in toward this central star, the sun,” Borlina says. “Gravity is also playing a role. But we are now showing that, if you want to fully understand how the sun and planets formed, you should include magnetic fields in the ingredients that make them.”This research was supported, in part, by NASA.